One Reel, two inspected files
These are separate responses from the same approved public Reel, DLHx_WNoXoY. They are not tests of every Instagram source.
- MP4 response
- HTTP 200 · 11,097,563 bytes · 6.157 seconds to receive the body. Its audio stream was HE-AAC, 44,100 Hz, stereo, displayed at 76 kb/s.
- MP3 response
- HTTP 200 · 1,106,684 bytes · 5.378 seconds to receive the body. Its audio stream was MP3, 44,100 Hz, stereo, displayed at 283 kb/s.
A bitrate is not a listening-quality score. Comparing those two numbers across AAC and MP3 does not establish that the MP3 contains more original detail.
Measured October 3, 2026 (Asia/Shanghai), from DESKTOP-OC01O77, Windows 11 Pro 10.0.28000 x64, Node v24.19.0. The method was HTTPS POST to ig-reels-downloader.com/api/download, followed by FFmpeg 7.1 inspection of each response through standard input. Chrome was not used for these downloads. Different machines, server load and source versions can change the results.
The MP3 pipe inspection emitted “invalid concatenated file detected - using bitrate for duration” and reported duration as N/A. Its 283 kb/s figure is the probe’s displayed estimate, not a guaranteed constant bitrate. No listening score or sample-by-sample fidelity comparison was performed.
Keep the AAC track instead of converting it
For an MP4 you own or may use, FFmpeg’s -c:a copy copies the selected encoded audio stream without decoding and re-encoding it. The following local command is for an AAC track such as the one inspected above:
ffmpeg -i reel.mp4 -map 0:a:0 -vn -c:a copy reel-audio.m4aThis is a local extraction command, not a Vidlune M4A button. Our ordinary download endpoint currently offers MP4 and MP3, not a source-track M4A export.
The MP3 branch selects ba/b and requests --extract-audio --audio-format mp3 --audio-quality 0. A quality setting is not a stream-copy instruction or a promise of lossless audio.
Repeat the check without guessing from the extension
Submit the approved Reel URL with {"type":"reels","format":"mp4","url":"https://www.instagram.com/reel/DLHx_WNoXoY/"} to the download endpoint; repeat once with mp3. Inspect each saved file with ffmpeg -hide_banner -i filename. Compare the audio codec, sample rate and channels, not just the filename.
The two format requests share the regular download allowance; this inspection is not a reason to keep requesting the same files. Use files already saved when repeating the codec check.
A WAV produced by our experimental vocal separator is an estimate from mixed input, not the original isolated recording. A lossless output container does not undo the changes made by separation.
The user question and disagreement about MP3 conversion can be read in the original audio-fidelity discussion. Stream-copy behavior is documented by FFmpeg; comments in a discussion are not technical proof.
Use the instagram reel downloader for the video file, the MP3 guide for saving the soundtrack, or the vocal-separation guide for a different task.